|
PRIVATE HEALTHCARE CENTRAL
March 8, 2007
-- TOP STORY: SHOULD APPA SUPPORT A HOSPITALIST PROGRAM?
-- LOCAL STORY: THE HOSPITAL COMPUTER THAT REPLACED THE ADMITTING PHYSICIAN
-- EDITORIAL: IS OUR PRIVATE PHYSICIAN INFRASTRUCTURE DETERIORATING?
-- MEMBER NEWS: EMPLOYMENT NEEDS
|
TOP STORY: SHOULD APPA SUPPORT A HOSPITALIST PROGRAM?
For the moment,
the prospect of a new hospitalist group brought in
under contract by our hospital is remote. Both the
CEO and the Medical Director have made it clear that
this is not their intent. They realize that APPA and the
rest of our physician community would not support
this and such a group would have few if any patients
to care for.
Nonetheless, the debate about this issue has
exposed trends in hospital care, which may
necessitate a formal hospitalist program in the near
future. Consider the following:
- More of our primary care physicians are
pulling back from hospital work. Some admit but refer
all management to specialists whom they call in.
Others refer to specialists and ask them to admit. A
growing number sign out all hospital calls and
coverage to our current pulmonologist-hospitalists.
- More of our specialty physicians are pulling back
from hospital work. Many are much busier and more
productive in their offices, surgicenters and imaging
centers.
Hospital call and care is being turned over to junior
colleagues or fellows in local training
programs.
- Some observers now
complain
that all of this too often results in inefficiently
managed patients. Without someone assuming the
ultimate decision-making authority and coordinating
consultants’ recommendations, patients can languish
in a hospital bed.
The reasons for all
this are familiar. Primary care physicians are
narrowing their practices—away from complete
patient responsibility to limited or even so-called
micro practices. Reimbursements for hospital work
are relatively poor compared to outpatient
procedures and practice. The hassle factor is way
up—from InterQual computer hassles to admit a
patient
to calls from overstressed nurses at 4
a.m. If these
trends continue, pressure to further reduce length of
stay may force our hospital to act. We may face
internal dissension if enough primary physicians
cease functioning as admitting physicians and place
too much of a burden on specialists and our
pulmonologist-hospitalists. As the largest organized
group of physicians in our community, APPA should
carefully consider how this issue affects our private
healthcare culture. We should discuss further
whether we should encourage our own internal
solution before one is imposed upon us.
|
LOCAL STORY: THE HOSPITAL COMPUTER THAT REPLACED THE ADMITTING PHYSICIAN
There was
a time when a physician decided if a patient would
benefit from hospitalization and was able to write
hospital orders to accomplish that. Thanks to
Medicare(CMS), NHIC, and a company called
Lumetra, that is no longer the case. CMS rules for
hospital admission and bed assignment are now
based on the InterQual
criteria. The
computer containing the InterQual software sits in the
E.R. The severity of illness (i.e. “chest pain with
positive treponin") along with the intensity of service
(i.e. your orders) are entered in the algorithm by the
admitting nurse. In case you are wondering, the
criteria for chest pain run 5 pages in printed form. The
computer then determines if admission is judged
appropriate and where the patient should be cared
for. The patient’s past history and the physician’s
clinical judgment count for little in this age of
computerized decision-making. If the computer says
“Admit to CDU” instead of CCU, you can argue with
the admitting nurse or call the Medical
Director. One
wonders what our Medicare patients would think of
all this. Do they even know that their hospital is
completely controlled by CMS regulations and
bureaucracy?
|
EDITORIAL: IS OUR PRIVATE PHYSICIAN INFRASTRUCTURE DETERIORATING?
Private
physicians, especially primary care physicians, are
rapidly changing their manner of practice. The
reasons are numerous: - Medicare
reimbursements for ancillary procedures financially
supporting office practice have been cut sharply in
2007 and will be cut further. Paltry increases in office
visit services do not adequately compensate for
these
cuts.
- PPO insurance
reimbursements fall as Medicare rates fall. These
contracts peg payments to a percentage of Medicare
rates. Blue Shield now pays 60% of a Medicare
allowable charge.
- Our governor
proposes a 2% tax on gross physician revenue.
Imagine an oncology practice with hundreds of
thousands of dollars in gross income from
chemotherapy with a currently small profit margin.
Net
income to the oncologist could drop
30%.
- Even more government
limitation on physician business practice. 2007 Stark
rules further restrict the manner and location of
physician imaging services.
- Practice
overhead grows relentlessly.
Southern California has the highest overhead in the
country.
- Practice growth is almost
impossible. With our backs to the sea, our
marketplace is limited. Recruitment of new
physicians
in order to grow is next to impossible because of our
cost of living.
- Caring for hospitalized
patients has become a poor use of an office-based
physician’s time. Reimbursements relative to time
involved are low. The hassle factor outweighs the
professional obligation for many. Fighting with an
InterQual computer to get a patient admitted and
taking phone calls from discharge planners and
hospital administrators wanting a patient discharged
becomes too much to
take.
How
are
physicians adapting? By making major changes in
their manner
of practice:- Accepting no new Medicare
patients.
- Limiting under 65 new patients to well patient
care
- Narrowing the scope of practice--micropractice.
- Employing mid-level practitioners such as PAs
and NPs to limit patient time commitment.
- Increasing throughput--shorter visit times
- Limiting office hassles—less telephone
access.
- Adding even more ancillaries—DEXA,
ultrasound,
stress testing.
- Adding “access fees” for uncovered, preventive
services.
- Adding cash pay services—botox, laser and skin
treatments product sales,
- Doing med-legal work
- Transfering hospital care to junior associates if in
group practice.
- Transfering hospital care to “hospitalists” if in solo
practice.
- Considering early retirement.
How does all this
affect our private healthcare infrastructure? Primarily
in
ways which do not benefit our sick patients.
- Fewer physicians available to see new sick
patients.
- Less physician time available for sick patient
care,
more time spent on ancillary procedures and
services.
- Less time for interaction among primary
physicians and consultants in the care of sick
patients.
- Less efficient hospital care by “hospitalists” who
have less information about and no relationship with
sick patients they admit.
- Deterioration of our physician-patient
relationships, loss of loyalty from our patient base,
potential loss of our unique marketshare.
Private
physicians practice a relationship based profession.
We know that there is no more powerful tool than the
therapeutic relationship we have with each patient as
a unique individual battling a disease. Our
effectiveness as well as our professional happiness
is in large measure determined by how well we
maintain this unique
bond.
None
of us can be truly successful in a relationship-based
private practice alone. Without colleagues and
consultants who practice as we do and a hospital
environment that supports us, we face nothing but
frustration. We need to recognize changes in our
infrastructure as they occur, continue to discuss them,
and evolve in ways that enhance our private
healthcare culture instead of damaging
it.
That is
one man’s opinion. I look forward to yours.
Richard L. Taw M.D.
|
MEMBER NEWS: EMPLOYMENT NEEDS
APPA
would like to
assist our members when
they are in need of employees, or know of someone
looking for work, please contact the office at
(310) 453
-0169.
Private
Healthcare
Central
is a publication of
the
American Private Physicians Association. Direct
comments or questions to Pamela Deloney,
administrator for APPA.
|
Quick Links...
Our Website
HSA Insider
Consumers for Healthcare Choices
HSA Finders
|
Contact Information
phone:
(310) 453-0169
|